TOPICS
Search

Ulam Floating Body Problem


The Ulam floating body problem asks whether a homogeneous convex body in three-dimensional Euclidean space that floats in equilibrium in every orientation must be a closed ball. It is Problem 19 of the Scottish Book, proposed by Ulam, and also appears in Ulam (1960, p. 38). The density of the surrounding fluid is normalized to 1, and the density D of the body satisfies 0<D<1.

For each orientation, a plane cuts off the submerged fraction D of the body's volume. Equilibrium requires the center of mass of the body and the geometric centroid of the submerged portion to lie on a line perpendicular to this plane (Ryabogin 2022).

Ryabogin (2022), whose result was first announced in 2021, gave a negative answer at D=1/2. For every dimension d>=3, he constructed a strictly convex body of revolution in R^d that is not a closed ball but floats in equilibrium in every orientation with half its volume submerged. In three dimensions, this is a solid of revolution. The counterexamples are small smooth perturbations of a closed ball and are not centrally symmetric. The symmetry qualification is essential. At density 1/2, a centrally symmetric convex body floating in every orientation must be a closed ball (Schneider 1970, Ryabogin 2022).

The convex floating body construction instead takes an intersection of half-spaces obtained by cutting caps of prescribed volume from a given convex body. It does not impose the equilibrium condition in Ulam's problem.


See also

Convex Body, Convex Floating Body, Scottish Book

Explore with Wolfram|Alpha

References

Ryabogin, D. "A Negative Answer to Ulam's Problem 19 from the Scottish Book." Ann. Math. 195, 1111-1150, 2022. https://doi.org/10.4007/annals.2022.195.3.5.Schneider, R. "Functional Equations Connected with Rotations and Their Geometric Applications." Enseign. Math. 16, 297-305, 1970. https://doi.org/10.5169/seals-43867.Ulam, S. M. A Collection of Mathematical Problems. New York: Interscience Publishers, p. 38, 1960.

Cite this as:

Weisstein, Eric W. "Ulam Floating Body Problem." From MathWorld--A Wolfram Resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/UlamFloatingBodyProblem.html

Subject classifications