Trigonometric functions of radians for
an integer not divisible by 3 (e.g.,
and
) cannot be expressed in terms of sums, products,
and finite root extractions on rational
numbers because 9 is not a product of distinct Fermat
primes. This also means that the regular nonagon
is not a constructible polygon.
However, exact expressions involving roots of complex numbers can still be derived using the trigonometric identity
(1)
|
Let
and
.
Then the above identity gives the cubic equation
(2)
|
(3)
|
This cubic is of the form
(4)
|
where
(5)
| |||
(6)
|
The polynomial discriminant is then
(7)
|
There are therefore three real distinct roots, which are approximately , 0.3420, and 0.6428. We want the one in the first quadrant, which is approximately 0.3420.
(8)
| |||
(9)
| |||
(10)
| |||
(11)
|
Similarly,
(12)
| |||
(13)
|
Because of the Vieta's formulas, we have the identities
(14)
|
(15)
|
(16)
|
(15) is known as Morrie's law.
Ramanujan found the interesting identity
(17)
|
(Borwein and Bailey 2003, p. 77; Trott 2004, p. 64).