TOPICS
Search

Minkowski's Question Mark Function


MinkowskiQuestionMark

Minkowski's question mark function is the strictly increasing function y=?(x) on [0,1] defined by ?(0)=0 and

 ?(x)=sum_(k=1)^infty((-1)^(k-1))/(2^((a_1+...+a_k)-1))
(1)

for 0<x<=1 with continued fraction x=[0;a_1,a_2,a_3,...], with the sum terminating for rational x. It maps quadratic surds in the open interval (0,1) to rational numbers in that interval in a continuous, order-preserving manner. For the nonnegative arguments outside [0,1] used below, the extension is ?(m+x)=m+?(x) for a nonnegative integer m and 0<=x<=1.

It is implemented in the Wolfram Language as MinkowskiQuestionMark[x].

On [0,1], the function satisfies the following properties (Salem 1943).

1. ?(x) is a strictly increasing function.

2. If x is rational, then ?(x) is of the form k/2^s, with k and s integers.

3. If x is a quadratic surd, then its continued fraction is eventually periodic, and hence ?(x) is rational.

4. The function is purely singular (Denjoy 1938).

The function ?(x) can also be constructed as

 ?((p+p^')/(q+q^'))=(?(p/q)+?(p^'/q^'))/2,
(2)

where p/q and p^'/q^' are two consecutive irreducible fractions from a Farey sequence. Starting with 0/1 and 1/1, insert the mediant between each adjacent pair at every stage. After n stages, ?(x) is defined at 2^n+1 arguments, and the corresponding ordinates are y=k/2^n for k=0, 1, ..., 2^n (Salem 1943).

For positive integers k and n, the function satisfies the identity

 ?(1/(k^n))=1/(2^(k^n-1)).
(3)

A few special values include

?(0)=0
(4)
?(1/3)=1/4
(5)
?(1/2)=1/2
(6)
?(phi-1)=2/3
(7)
?(2/3)=3/4
(8)
?(1/2sqrt(2))=4/5
(9)
?(1/2sqrt(3))=(84)/(85)
(10)
?(1)=1,
(11)

where phi is the golden ratio.

The function satisfies the symmetry

 ?(1-x)=1-?(x),
(12)

where x in [0,1]. Its only rational fixed points on [0,1] are 0, 1/2, and 1. There are also irrational fixed points f and 1-f, where f=0.420372339... (OEIS A048819) is the Minkowski-Bower constant, the smallest positive fixed point. It is conjectured that these five fixed points are the only ones on [0,1], or four modulo 1 (Gayfulin and Shulga 2020).

Values x with large terms in their continued fractions cause ?(x) to have a large section of repeating 0's or 9's (E. Pegg, Jr., pers. comm., Jan. 5, 2023). Some examples include

?(6^(1/3))=1.9530189847656249...9_()_(142)6...
(13)
?(20^(1/3))=2.81250...0_()_(43)2...
(14)
?(pi)=3.01562476158142089843749...9_()_(72)8....
(15)

See also

Devil's Staircase, Farey Sequence, Minkowski-Bower Constant

Explore with Wolfram|Alpha

References

Bailey, D. H.; Borwein, J. M.; Calkin, N. J.; Girgensohn, R.; Luke, D. R.; and Moll, V. H. Experimental Mathematics in Action. Wellesley, MA: A K Peters, pp. 237-238, 2007.Conway, J. H. "Contorted Fractions." On Numbers and Games, 2nd ed. Wellesley, MA: A K Peters, pp. 82-86 (1st ed.), 2000.Denjoy, A. "Sur une fonction réelle de Minkowski." J. Math. Pures Appl. 17, 105-155, 1938.Finch, S. R. "Minkowski-Bower Constant." §6.9 in Mathematical Constants. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, pp. 441-443, 2003.Gayfulin, D. and Shulga, N. A. "Diophantine Properties of Fixed Points of Minkowski Question Mark Function." Acta Arith. 195, 367-382, 2020. https://doi.org/10.4064/aa181209-18-9.Girgensohn, R. "Constructing Singular Functions via Farey Fractions." J. Math. Anal. Appl. 203, 127-141, 1996.Kinney, J. R. "Note on a Singular Function of Minkowski." Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 11, 788-794, 1960.Minkowski, H. "Zur Geometrie der Zahlen." In Gesammelte Abhandlungen, Vol. 2. New York: Chelsea, pp. 44-52, 1991.Salem, R. "On Some Singular Monotone Functions Which Are Strictly Increasing." Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 53, 427-439, 1943.Sloane, N. J. A. Sequence A048819 in "The On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences."Tichy, R. and Uitz, J. "An Extension of Minkowski's Singular Functions." Appl. Math. Lett. 8, 39-46, 1995.Viader, P.; Paradis, J.; and Bibiloni, L. "A New Light on Minkowski's ?(x) Function." J. Number Th. 73, 212-227, 1998.Yakubovich, S. "The Affirmative Solution to Salem's Problem Revisited." 31 Dec 2014. https://arxiv.org/abs/1501.00141.

Referenced on Wolfram|Alpha

Minkowski's Question Mark Function

Cite this as:

Weisstein, Eric W. "Minkowski's Question Mark Function." From MathWorld--A Wolfram Resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/MinkowskisQuestionMarkFunction.html

Subject classifications