Baker's question asks whether a fixed smooth variety over a finite
field, which is a quasiprojective variety
of pure positive dimension, has the following property.
For every sufficiently large
, every embedding
into projective space
whose connected components lie in no hyperplane
admits a hyperplane defined over the field whose intersection
with
is a smooth variety of dimension
(Poonen 2004, Question 4.1).
The question is related to Bertini's theorem, but varies the embedding and keeps the polynomial degree of the section equal to 1. Poonen's finite-field Bertini theorem instead fixes the embedding and allows the polynomial degree of a hypersurface to grow (Poonen 2004).
Zhang and Yang (2026a) reported a negative answer for every nonempty smooth variety
over a finite field
whose components all have the same positive dimension
and which is a quasiprojective variety.
For every sufficiently large
, they construct a locally closed
embedding
into projective space such that no connected
component lies in a hyperplane, even after any
field extension, but every hyperplane
defined over
cuts out a section with a singular point. The claim
concerns particular embeddings, not all embeddings.
Zhang and Yang (2026a) report GPT assistance with Lean formalizations of selected proof components. As of Oct. 2, 2026, the accompanying Lean development remained conditional on geometric lemmas left unproved in Lean, and independent specialist review of the complete argument had not been reported (Zhang and Yang 2026b, VibeMathed 2026).