TOPICS
Search

von Neumann's Elephant


Von Neumann's elephant is a recreational problem of describing an elephant-shaped plane curve using only four parameters. The problem grew out of a remark attributed to John von Neumann by Enrico Fermi, as recalled by Dyson (2004), "With four parameters I can fit an elephant, and with five I can make him wiggle his trunk." Fermi used the remark in a 1953 discussion with Dyson to question whether agreement with data obtained by adjusting several arbitrary parameters was sufficient evidence for a physical model (Dyson 2004).

vonNeumannsElephant

Mayer et al. (2010) constructed a schematic elephant using truncated Fourier series. Interchanging the coordinate labels in their coefficient table gives the parametric equations

x(t)=-60cost+30sint-8sin(2t)+10sin(3t)
(1)
y(t)=50sint+18sin(2t)-12cos(3t)+14cos(5t),
(2)

where 0<=t<=2pi. Their four complex parameters are 50-30i, 18+8i, 12-10i, and -14-60i. The real part and imaginary part of each supply two of the eight nonzero Fourier coefficients in these equations. The choice of which Fourier coefficients vanish is part of the prescribed model. Thus the construction uses four complex numbers, equivalent to eight real parameters, rather than four real parameters. A fifth complex number specifies the additional trunk-motion control and the eye in the authors' construction (Mayer et al. 2010).

vonNeumannsElephant2

Jin and Yuan (2024) give a frontal view using a polar curve with four nonconstant Fourier coefficients. In a convenient orientation, their curve can be written

 r(q)=c+2+31.58cos(8q)+47.84sinq+51.12sin(3q)+20.43sin(7q).
(3)

The elephant appears when r(q) is drawn in polar coordinates, rather than plotted as an ordinary graph of r against q. The offset c is about 200 in the authors' pixel scale. Changing it shifts all radial distances and therefore changes the proportions of the curve, although modest changes leave the elephant shape recognizable. The resulting curve traces a stylized frontal view with two ears, two tusks, and a trunk. The four harmonic indices, the zero coefficients, and the choice of a symmetric frontal view are also fixed in advance. The authors therefore describe their result as satisfying a weaker requirement of four nonzero coefficients, rather than an unrestricted four-parameter description.

These constructions illustrate why a parameter count must specify what is allowed to vary and what is built into the representation. Piantadosi (2018) gives a related construction based on the logistic map in which one real parameter can fit arbitrarily many data values in (0,1) at distinct nonnegative integer arguments to any fixed positive accuracy. The information is encoded in the digits of that parameter, so counting parameters alone does not measure the complexity of a model or its predictive value.


See also

Fourier Series, Least Squares Fitting, Parameter, Parametric Equations, Plane Curve, Polar Curve

Explore with Wolfram|Alpha

References

Big Think. "One of the World's Greatest Mathematicians Explains 6 Essential Concepts of Math." Featuring T. Tao. 2026. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OOMx2BHHWtE.Dyson, F. "A Meeting with Enrico Fermi." Nature 427, 297, 2004. https://doi.org/10.1038/427297a.Jin, D. and Yuan, J. "Fitting an Elephant with Four Non-Zero Parameters." 2 Jul 2024. https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.07909. Code: https://github.com/CLaSLoVe/von-Neumann-elephant.Mayer, J.; Khairy, K.; and Howard, J. "Drawing an Elephant with Four Complex Parameters." Amer. J. Phys. 78, 648-649, 2010. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.3254017.Piantadosi, S. T. "One Parameter Is Always Enough." AIP Advances 8, 095118, 2018. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5031956.

Cite this as:

Weisstein, Eric W. "von Neumann's Elephant." From MathWorld--A Wolfram Resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/vonNeumannsElephant.html

Subject classifications