TOPICS
Search

Strong Kakeya Property


A set E in the Euclidean plane has the strong Kakeya property if, for every epsilon>0 and every two orientation-preserving isometries rho_1 and rho_2, there is a continuous rigid motion from rho_1(E) to rho_2(E) whose swept set has Lebesgue measure interpreted as outer measure less than epsilon (Csörnyei et al. 2017, Joseph et al. 2026). This extends the small-area motion question in the Kakeya needle problem to sets other than a line segment.

Joseph et al. (2026) proved that a circle with two antipodal points removed has the strong Kakeya property in the plane. On a sphere, a subset of a great circle has the corresponding property under continuous rotations iff its complement within that great circle contains two antipodal points. A line with one point removed has the property with respect to any finite Borel measure that is absolutely continuous with respect to Lebesgue measure; this is a different assertion from using ordinary plane area.

They also proved a stronger distinction between the motion of one point and the rest of a line segment. Given any point q of a line segment E, any bounded plane set S, and any epsilon>0, a continuous rigid motion P can satisfy

 area(P[E\{q}])<epsilon, area(S\P[{q}])<epsilon,

where area means Lebesgue measure interpreted as outer measure and P[A] denotes the union of all positions of A during the motion. Thus one point can traverse almost all of a prescribed bounded set while all the other points collectively sweep arbitrarily little area. For any open line segment E and any nonzero vector v not perpendicular to it, they further constructed a fixed continuous motion P for which the function t|->area(P[E+tv]) is discontinuous.


See also

Kakeya Needle Problem, Lebesgue Measure, Rigid Motion

Explore with Wolfram|Alpha

References

Csörnyei, M.; Héra, K.; and Laczkovich, M. "Closed Sets with the Kakeya Property." Mathematika 63, 184-195, 2017. https://doi.org/10.1112/S0025579316000188.Joseph, B.; Keleti, T.; Kökényesi, M.; Máthé, A.; and Schmidt, A. "Continuous Kakeya Type Problems with Special Points That Sweep Much More Area than the Rest." 16 Nov 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.21316v1.

Cite this as:

Weisstein, Eric W. "Strong Kakeya Property." From MathWorld--A Wolfram Resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/StrongKakeyaProperty.html

Subject classifications