The Schmeisser conjecture strengthens the Sendov conjecture by replacing a root of a polynomial
by an arbitrary point in the convex
hull of all its roots. Specifically, if a polynomial has polynomial
degree
and all its roots lie in the closed unit
disk, then every
in their convex hull is within
distance 1 of a critical
point of
(Schmeisser 1977). Zhang (2026) reports a computer-assisted proof
in every polynomial degree. The constant 1 is
sharp for each
, as shown by
. The proof uses analytic estimates in high
degrees and interval certificates for degrees 4 through 6000. Zhang (2026) also reports
that Codex generated a Lean formalization checked by the Lean kernel.
The same assertion with 1 replaced by the centered root moment from the Borcea
variance conjecture fails for every finite
. Indeed, for an integer
, take
and
. Its critical
points are 0 and
, so the nearest is at distance
, whereas
(Zhang
2026). This refutes the convex-hull strengthening and does not refute the root-only
Borcea conjecture.