A hereditarily ordinal definable set is a set whose singleton set has a transitive closure consisting entirely of ordinal definable sets. A set is ordinal definable if it is uniquely definable in the universe of sets by a first-order formula with finitely many ordinal numbers as parameters. The hereditary condition includes the set itself. The class of all such sets, denoted HOD, is a transitive class containing all ordinal numbers and satisfying the Zermelo-Fraenkel axioms with the axiom of choice (Jech 2003).
Woodin's HOD hypothesis asserts that there are arbitrarily large regular cardinals that are not -strongly measurable in HOD. A cardinal is regular if its
cofinality equals itself and singular if its cofinality
is smaller. For an uncountable regular cardinal
, the latter property means that there is a cardinal
with
and no partition belonging to HOD of
into
stationary sets (Woodin 2017). Here
is the cofinality; stationary
means meeting every closed unbounded subset of
, with stationarity computed in the ambient universe.
A closed unbounded subset is unbounded and contains all
its limit points below
.
Under the HOD hypothesis and a supercompact cardinal , there are unboundedly many singular cardinals
whose cofinality and successor cardinal HOD computes
correctly (Goldberg et al. 2026, Theorem 4.4 and Corollary 4.5).
Nevertheless, starting from the generalized
continuum hypothesis and a supercompact
cardinal, there is a forcing extension satisfying the HOD hypothesis in which
the least supercompact cardinal
carries a closed unbounded set
of cardinals
that HOD regards as regular and for which
(Goldberg et al. 2026, Theorem 4.6). These are compatibility and relative
consistency statements, not a contradiction between unbounded agreement and closed
unbounded failure.
If
is supercompact and the HOD hypothesis fails, then for any cardinal
there is a forcing extension preserving the supercompactness
of
and failure of the HOD hypothesis in which every subset
of
belongs to HOD (Goldberg et al. 2026, Theorem 4.9).