Take itself to be a bracketing, then recursively
define a bracketing as a sequence
where
and each
is a bracketing. A bracketing can be represented
as a parenthesized string of
s, with parentheses removed from any single letter
for clarity of notation (Stanley 1997). Bracketings built
up of binary operations only are called binary
bracketings. For example, four letters have 11 possible bracketings:
(1)
|
the last five of which are binary.
The number of bracketings on letters is given by the generating
function
(2)
|
(Schröder 1870, Stanley 1997) and the recurrence relation
(3)
|
(Comtet 1974), giving the sequence for as 1, 1, 3, 11, 45, 197, 903, ... (OEIS A001003).
They are therefore equivalent to the super Catalan
numbers.
A closed form expression in terms of Legendre polynomials
for
is
(4)
| |||
(5)
|
(Vardi 1991, p. 199).
The numbers are also given by
(6)
|
for (Stanley 1997).
The first Plutarch number is equal to
(Stanley 1997), suggesting that Plutarch's problem of
ten compound propositions is equivalent to the number of bracketings. In addition,
Plutarch's second number
is given by
(Habsieger et al. 1998).