TOPICS
Search

Banach-Mazur Rotation Problem


The Banach-Mazur rotation problem asks whether a separable real Banach space whose surjective linear isometries act transitively on its unit sphere must be isometrically a Hilbert space. Transitivity means that for any unit vectors x and y there is a surjective linear isometry satisfying T(x)=y (Randrianantoanina 2002).

The finite-dimensional case is classical. A transitive real normed space of finite dimension has a norm induced by an inner product. Blore (2026) gives a Lean proof of this case, with published kernel acceptance recorded by the Palomar Registry. The separable infinite-dimensional problem remains open. Without separability, transitive non-Hilbert examples exist (Randrianantoanina 2002).

A weaker condition is almost transitivity, meaning that each group orbit is dense in the unit sphere. Randrianantoanina (2002) proved that a real almost transitive Banach space of dimension at least 3 is isometrically a Hilbert space if it has a hyperplane which is the range of a bounded operator P(x) satisfying P(P(x))=P(x) and having operator norm 1. This is a conditional result and does not settle the general rotation problem.


See also

Banach Space, Hilbert Space, Isometry, Normed Space

Explore with Wolfram|Alpha

References

Blore, Z. "The Banach-Mazur Rotation Problem in Finite Dimensions: A Transitive Isometry Group Forces a Euclidean Norm." Palomar Registry, 2026. https://palomar-registry.org/entry.html?id=PALOMAR-2026-11-07-000013&version=1.Randrianantoanina, B. "A Note on the Banach-Mazur Problem." Glasgow Math. J. 44, 159-165, 2002. https://doi.org/10.1017/S001708950201011X.

Cite this as:

Weisstein, Eric W. "Banach-Mazur Rotation Problem." From MathWorld--A Wolfram Resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/Banach-MazurRotationProblem.html

Subject classifications