An ordinary line of a point arrangement is a line containing exactly two of its points. Dirac (1951) conjectured
that every sufficiently large set of noncollinear points contains at
least
ordinary lines (Borwein and Bailey 2003, p. 18), and
Green and Tao (2013) proved this conjecture.
Csima and Sawyer (1993) proved that every arrangement of noncollinear points determines
at least
ordinary lines. The stronger all- version of Dirac's bound has two known exceptions: the Kelly-Moser
configuration (7 points, 3 ordinary lines;
cf. Fano plane) and McKee's configuration (13 points,
6 ordinary lines).
More generally, a line spanned by a finitepoint set is -ordinary
if it contains at most points of , and a -ordinary triangle is a noncollinear triple whose three side
lines are -ordinary. If , no line
contains more than
of the points, and the points cannot be
covered by two lines, then there are 17-ordinary triangles (Dumitrescu and Pach 2026).
They also gave an algorithm to count all -ordinary triangles when .
da Silva and Fukuda conjectured that every noncollinear, line-separable two-color arrangement with color classes whose sizes differ by at most one has a bichromatic
ordinary line. Finschi and Fukuda (2001) found a unique nine-point counterexample,
up to isomorphism, among 15296266 distinct configurations. Its color classes have
four and five points; the equal-size case is not refuted
by this example.
For coordinates in the complex numbers, a nonconcentration hypothesis gives a quadratic lower bound. Kroeker and Lund (2026) proved that distinct points
in determine at least ordinary lines if no affine plane
contains more than
of the points. The constant is not known to be sharp.
Borwein, J. and Bailey, D. Mathematics by Experiment: Plausible Reasoning in the 21st Century. Wellesley, MA: A
K Peters, 2003.Coxeter, H. S. M. "A Problem of Collinear
Points." Amer. Math. Monthly55, 26-28, 1948.Coxeter,
H. S. M. The
Real Projective Plane, 3rd ed. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press,
1993.Csima, J. and Sawyer, E. "There Exist Ordinary Points." Disc. Comput. Geom.9,
187-202, 1993.de Bruijn, N. G. and Erdős, P. "On a Combinatorial
Problem." Hederl. Adad. Wetenach.51, 1277-1279, 1948.Dirac,
G. A. "Collinearity Properties of Sets of Points." Quart. J. Math.2,
221-227, 1951.Dumitrescu, A. and Pach, J. "Note on the Number of
Almost Ordinary Triangles." Elec. J. Combin.33, P3.33, 2026.
https://doi.org/10.37236/14703.Erdős,
P. "Problem 4065." Amer. Math. Monthly51, 169, 1944.Felsner,
S. Geometric
Graphs and Arrangements. Wiesbaden, Germany: Vieweg, 2004.Finschi,
L. and Fukuda, K. "The Da Silva-Fukuda Conjecture." 6 Apr 2001. https://finschi.com/math/publ/2001-04-06_Finschi-Fukuda_Da-Silva-Fukuda-Conjecture.html.Green,
B. and Tao, T. "On Sets Defining Few Ordinary Lines." Disc. Comput.
Geom.50, 409-468, 2013. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00454-013-9518-9.Guy,
R. K. "Unsolved Problems Come of Age." Amer. Math. Monthly96,
903-909, 1989.Kaneko, A. and Kano, M. "Discrete Geometry on Red
and Blue Points in the Plane." http://gorogoro.cis.ibaraki.ac.jp/web/papers/kano2003-48.pdf.Kelly,
L. M. and Moser, W. O. J. "On the Number of Ordinary Lines Determined
by Points." Canad. J. Math.1,
210-219, 1958.Kroeker, M. E. and Lund, B. "Ordinary Lines,
Point Degrees, and Matroid Density." 15 Oct 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.21415.Lang,
D. W. "The Dual of a Well-Known Theorem." Math. Gaz.39,
314, 1955.Malkevitch, J. "A Discrete Geometrical Gem." https://www.ams.org/publicoutreach/feature-column/fcarc-sylvester1.Motzkin,
T. "The Lines and Planes Connecting the Points of a Finite Set." Trans.
Amer. Math. Soc.70, 451-463, 1951.Sylvester, J. J.
"Mathematical Question 11851." Educational Times59, 98,
1893.