TOPICS
Search

Laplace Limit


KapteynLemon

The Laplace limit is the greatest orbital eccentricity for which Laplace's series solution of Kepler's equation converges.

For a complex number z=re^(itheta)=x+iy, the inequality

 |(zexp(sqrt(1-z^2)))/(1+sqrt(1-z^2))|<=1
(1)

describes the lens-shaped region illustrated above. In terms of real variables, the same region is described by

 1+lambda+sqrt(2(1+lambda-x^2+y^2))>=(x^2+y^2)exp[sqrt(2(1+lambda-x^2+y^2))],
(2)

where

 lambda=sqrt([(1-x)^2+y^2][(1+x)^2+y^2]).
(3)

This region can be parameterized in terms of a variable u as

r^2=(2u)/(sinh(2u))
(4)
sin^2theta=sinhu(ucoshu-sinhu).
(5)

Written parametrically in terms of the Cartesian coordinates,

x(u)=sqrt(u(cothu-u))
(6)
y(u)=sqrt(u(u-tanhu)).
(7)

The parameter u has maximum value u^*=1.1996786403... (OEIS A085984; Le Lionnais 1983, p. 36), the unique positive root of

 cothu=u,
(8)

or equivalently of

 e^u(u-1)=e^(-u)(u+1),
(9)

Goursat (1959, p. 120) credits Stieltjes with the numerical value.

By symmetry, the area enclosed is therefore

A=-4int_0^(u^*)y(u)x^'(u)du
(10)
=2int_0^(u^*)sqrt((u-tanhu)/(cothu-u))(ucsch^2u+2u-cothu)du.
(11)

Another exact reduction is obtained by defining p(U)=e^(2U)(U-1)/(U+1) and pairing two values U and V on the physical reflection sheet so that p(U)p(V)=1. With S=U+V, this equation factors as

 S[(sinhS)/S(UV+1)-coshS]=0,
(12)

where sinhS/S is defined to be 1 at S=0. The first component is U+V=0, or V=-U. Although explicit, it is not the physical reflection sheet. At the cubic cusp U=V=0, continuation of the physical area switches instead to the nontrivial component

 UV=ScothS-1.
(13)

On the nontrivial component, define q=UV=ScothS-1 and

a=q+1-S
(14)
b=q+1+S
(15)
t=ae^(-a)=be^(-b)
(16)
-a=W_0(-t)
(17)
-b=W_(-1)(-t).
(18)

For 0<S<=2u^*, 0<a<1<b, while a=b=1 at S=0. Together, these relations give omega(0,-a)=-b, the ordinary transition between the W_0 and W_(-1) branches of the Lambert W-function studied by Åhag et al. (2024).

Setting

R=S/(sinhS)
(19)
R^2=(q+1)^2-S^2=S^2csch^2S
(20)
D^2=4q-S^2=4ScothS-4-S^2
(21)

with D>0 for 0<S<2u^* gives the exact area representation

 A=int_0^(2u^*)(qR)/DdS.
(22)

Equivalently, this is the explicit integral

 A=int_0^(2u^*)(S(ScothS-1))/(sinhSsqrt(4ScothS-4-S^2))dS,
(23)

which agrees numerically with the parametrized formula above. Here L_n^((1))(x) is an associated Laguerre polynomial, also called a generalized Laguerre polynomial. An exact series representation for the area is

A=(4pi)/(e^2)[1+sum_(k=1)^(infty)([L_(k-1)^((1))(4k+2)+L_k^((1))(4k+2)]^2)/((2k+1)e^(4k))]
(24)
=1.8532684487....
(25)

(OEIS A140133). While the preceding representations are exact, they do not constitute a finite closed form free of both integration and an infinite sum.

This region is intimately related to the study of Bessel functions and Kapteyn series (Plummer 1960, p. 47; Watson 1966, p. 270).

LaplaceLimit

The minimum value of r corresponding to the maximum value u^* is r^*=0.6627434... (OEIS A033259; Plummer 1960, p. 47; Watson 1966, p. 270), which is known as the Laplace limit constant. It is the convergence threshold for Laplace's series solution of Kepler's equation and is the unique real number e satisfying f(e)=1, where

 f(x)=(xexp(sqrt(1+x^2)))/(1+sqrt(1+x^2)).
(26)

The same constant controls the existence of a catenoid spanning two equal coaxial circles of radius R whose planes are separated by a distance h: such a catenoid exists only for h/R<=2r^*. At equality it is the critical catenoid, and the volume bounded by the catenoid and its two boundary disks is piR^2h/2 (Anderson 2026).

The continued fraction of e is given by [0, 1, 1, 1, 27, 1, 1, 1, 8, 2, 154, ...] (OEIS A033260). The positions of the first occurrences of n in the continued fraction of e are 2, 10, 35, 13, 15, 32, 101, 9, ... (OEIS A033261). The incrementally largest terms in the continued fraction are 1, 27, 154, 1601, 2135, ... (OEIS A033262), which occur at positions 2, 5, 11, 19, 1801, ... (OEIS A033263).


See also

Critical Catenoid, Eccentric Anomaly, Hyperbolic Cotangent, Kepler's Equation, Kapteyn Series, Minimal Surface of Revolution

Explore with Wolfram|Alpha

References

Åhag, P.; Czyż, R.; and Lundow, P.-H. "On a Generalised Lambert W Branch Transition Function Arising from p,q-Binomial Coefficients." Appl. Math. Comput. 462, 128347, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amc.2023.128347.Anderson, T. "The Volume of the Critical Catenoid." Math. Intelligencer, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00283-026-10551-0.Finch, S. R. "Laplace Limit Constant." §4.8 in Mathematical Constants. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, pp. 266-268, 2003.Goursat, E. A Course in Mathematical Analysis, Vol. 2: Functions of a Complex Variable & Differential Equations. New York: Dover, p. 120, 1959.Le Lionnais, F. Les nombres remarquables. Paris, France: Hermann, p. 36, 1983.Leibovici, C. "Is There a Closed Form of the Laplace Limit Constant: x Such That xe^(sqrt(x^2+1))/(sqrt(x^2+1)+1)=1 Using Library Functions?" Mar. 12, 2022. https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/4393448/is-there-a-closed-form-of-the-laplace-limit-constant-x-such-that-fracxe.Moulton, F. R. "The Problem of Two Bodies." Ch. V in An Introduction to Celestial Mechanics, 2nd ed. New York: MacMillan, 1914.Plummer, H. An Introductory Treatise of Dynamical Astronomy. New York: Dover, 1960.Sloane, N. J. A. Sequences A033259, A033260, A033261, A033262, A033263, A085984, and A140133 in "The On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences."Watson, G. N. A Treatise on the Theory of Bessel Functions, 2nd ed. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, 1966.

Referenced on Wolfram|Alpha

Laplace Limit

Cite this as:

Weisstein, Eric W. "Laplace Limit." From MathWorld--A Wolfram Resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/LaplaceLimit.html

Subject classifications