TOPICS
Search

Jordan Tuple Conjecture


The Jordan tuple conjecture of Ball and Helton (1980) proposed that every commuting 3-symmetric pair of bounded operators on a Hilbert space has a simultaneous extension to a Jordan family of order two. A commuting pair (T_1,T_2) is 3-symmetric when

 Q_T(s,t)=e^(-itT_2^*)e^(-isT_1^*)e^(isT_1)e^(itT_2)

is an operator-valued polynomial of total polynomial degree at most 2 in real s and t.

A Jordan family of order two has the form J_j=S_j+N_j, where the S_j are commuting Hermitian operators, S_iN_j=N_jS_i, and N_iN_j=0 for all i,j. An extension requires an isometry V into a larger Hilbert space satisfying J_jV=VT_j.

Evert and McCullough (2026) disproved the conjecture by constructing a commuting 3-symmetric pair with no such extension. The pair consists of coordinate-multiplication operators on a Sobolev space of C^3-valued functions on a sufficiently large disk, equipped with an equivalent Hilbert space norm. Its quadratic symbol has no polynomial factorization Q_T=G^*G, even when G takes values in an auxiliary Hilbert space. The authors credit GPT-6.1 with generating the counterexample, whose argument they checked and improved.


See also

Bounded Operator, Hermitian Operator, Hilbert Space

Explore with Wolfram|Alpha

References

Ball, J. A. and Helton, J. W. "Nonnormal Dilations, Disconjugacy and Constrained Spectral Factorization." Integral Eq. Operator Th. 3, 216-309, 1980. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01682993.Evert, E. and McCullough, S. "A Counterexample to the Jordan Tuple Conjecture of Ball and Helton." 14 Nov 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.19373v1.

Cite this as:

Weisstein, Eric W. "Jordan Tuple Conjecture." From MathWorld--A Wolfram Resource. https://mathworld.wolfram.com/JordanTupleConjecture.html

Subject classifications