The Jordan tuple conjecture of Ball and Helton (1980) proposed that every commuting 3-symmetric pair of bounded operators on a Hilbert space has a simultaneous extension to a Jordan
family of order two. A commuting pair is 3-symmetric when
is an operator-valued polynomial of total polynomial degree at most 2 in real and
.
A Jordan family of order two has the form , where the
are commuting Hermitian
operators,
, and
for all
. An extension requires an isometry
into a larger Hilbert space
satisfying
.
Evert and McCullough (2026) disproved the conjecture by constructing a commuting 3-symmetric pair with no such extension. The pair consists of coordinate-multiplication
operators on a Sobolev space of -valued functions on a sufficiently large disk,
equipped with an equivalent Hilbert space norm.
Its quadratic symbol has no polynomial factorization
, even when
takes values in an auxiliary Hilbert
space. The authors credit GPT-6.1 with generating the counterexample,
whose argument they checked and improved.